Содержание журналов

Баннер
PERSONA GRATA

Content of journals

Баннер
Баннер
Баннер
Баннер


SUMMARIES OF ARTICLES №  1  (92) 2016 - 3




 
LAW OF THE CIS COUNTRIES
Gayurov Sh. K.
The essence of the unitary enterprise
The author in the summary determines its position on the contentious issue of the essence of the unitary enterprise. According to him, the unitary enterprise "commercial entity of the State," and a special legal personality, endowed with a complex legal status, reflected in the fact that it simultaneously acts in public circulation on its own behalf and in their interests and in the interests of the state.
Keywords: legal personality, the state, the public interest, unitary enterprise.
Work bibliographic list
1. Poslanie Prezidenta Tadzhikistana Jemomali Rahmona ot 20. 01. 2016 g. // www. Avesta. tj. (Data obrashhenija: 24. 01. 2016 g.).
2. Kovaleva N. N. Administrativno – pravovoj status predprijatij: dis. ... kand.jur.nauk: – Saratov, 2001.
3. Strategii reformirovanija sistemy gosudarstvennogo upravlenija Respubliki Tadzhikistan na 2005– 2015 g., utverzhdennoe Ukazom Prezidenta RT ot 15.
03. 2006 g., # 1713. // [Jelektron. resurs] // ADLIJa :Centraliz. bank pravovoj informacii Respubliki Tadzhikistan. Versija 6.0 /M – vo justicii Respubliki Tadzhikistan. – Dushanbe, 2015.– 1 jelektron. opt.disk (CD ROM).
4. Poljakov S. B. Juridicheskaja otvetstvennost' gosudarstva. – M. – Juridicheskij mir, 2007.
5. Teorija gosudarstva i prava: uchebnik / pod red. Marchenko M. N. M. – Zercalo, 2009.

  
 
LAW OF THE CIS COUNTRIES
Iskoyan A. B.
State legal regulation of environmental protection in Armenia
Declaration of State Independence Armenia adopted in 1991, thus, becoming a sovereign subject of international law. The new status assumed elaboration of a new concept of economic, political and social development. In order to ensure fulfillment of the mentioned tasks, the country attached special attention to elaboration and adoption of environmental legislation which was new in its content, since the laws and by-laws in the sphere of nature protection should have to meet the international obligation of the country after independence was declared. To this end, key role had the Law of RA from 9 July 1991 On the Basics of RA legislation on nature protection”. It was a framework legal act which established the environmental policy of RA, thus, laying ground for elaboration of new legislation.
Keywords: state independence, economic policy, environmental policy, environmental legislation, protection of nature and environment, international obligations.
Work bibliographic list
1. Get'man A.P. Processual'nye normy i otnoshenija v jekologicheskom prave. Har'kov, 1994. S.4. Ego zhe: Vstup do teorii ekologo-procesual'nogo prava Ukraini. – Har'kiv: Osnova,1998.
2. Nashe obshhee budushhee. Doklad Mezhdunarodnoj komissii po okruzhajushhej srede i razvitiju(MKOSR). – M.: Progress, 1989.




LAW OF THE CIS COUNTRIES
Ishchenko N. S.
New milestone in the fight against corruption in the Republic of Belarus in light of the adoption of the new anti-corruption law
Corruption was a large problem today, no state, regardless of socio-economic and political system, has no absolute immunity to it. The Author in the article explores the challenges characteristic of the Republic of Belarus, considers what corruption threats brought into the country crisis, and how to respond to them. Are arguments about what contribution in the fight against corruption contribute to economic liberalization and de-bureaucratization; how to develop and propagate a "smart" anti-corruption policy. Analyzes the strengths and weaknesses of the new anti-corruption legislation of Belarus and proposes optimal algorithms anti-corruption struggle.
Keywords: anti-corruption legislation, Belarus, GRECO, the post-Soviet States, anti-corruption rating.
Work bibliographic list
1. Beljaev, N. Chto novogo v novom Zakone «O bor'be s korrupciej»? // [Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://liberalclub.biz/ rezhim dostupa 28.01. 2016.
2. Ishhenko, N. S. Belarus' i mirovoj opyt protivodejstvija korrupcii / N. S. Ishhenko. – Gomel': GGTU im.P. O. Suhogo, 2009. – 250 s.
3. Kratkoe rezjume ocenochnogo doklada GRECO po Belarusi // [Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa:http://charter97.org/ru/news/2015/5/27/153190/rezhim dostupa 28.01.2016.
4. Luzgin, I. I. Korrupcija i ejo obshhestvennaja opasnost': kurs lekcij dlja studentov nejuridicheskih special'nostej / I. I. Luzgin. – Novopolock: PGU, 2012. – 144 s.





LAW OF THE CIS COUNTRIES
Malikova G. R.
Self-government bodies in the mechanism of social partnership: economic and legal aspect (on the example of the Republic of Uzbekistan)
This publication deals with relationships of self-government bodies with local Khokimiats and business structures in mechanism of the social partnership development. In this point of view the author is trying to analyze conditions of issues which require detailed regulation in this field. The author performed endeavor of comprehensive investigation of the makhalla institution. Studying of interdisciplinary approach just got started, this publication is one of verge of tasks which require their solution.
Keywords: makhalla, meeting of citizens, aksakal, makhalla guzars, local governments (khokimiyat), khashar, local economy.
Work bibliographic list
1. Au T. I. K voprosu o ponjatii social'nogo partnjorstva (s uchjotom specifiki Kazahstana). // Konstitucionnoe i municipal'noe pravo. – 2012. – # 11.
2. Vedomosti palat Olij Mazhlisa Respubliki Uzbekistan. – 2012. – # 7. – St. 190.
3. Koksharova A. A. Social'noe partnerstvo organov mestnogo samoupravlenija, obshhestvennyh organizacij i biznesa //Vektor nauki. TGU. – 2009. – # 1(4).
4. Koncepcii Dal'nejshego uglublenija jekonomicheskih reform i formirovanija grazhdanskogo obshhestva //Doklad Prezidenta Islama Karimova na sovmestnom zasedanii Zakonodatel'noj palaty i Senata Olij Mazhlisa Respubliki Uzbekistan. 12 nojabrja, 2010.
5. Markvart Je. Sovremennyj municipalitet – fabrika uslug ili platforma dlja grazhdanskogo obshhestva? //Praktika municipal'nogo upravlenija. – 2013. – # 3.
6. Nabiraev A. Social'noe partnjorstvo kak princip vzaimnoj otvetstvennosti // Narodnoe slovo. – 2011.– 24 ijulja.
7. Oficial'nyj otvet Gosudarstvennogo komiteta «Uzergeodezkadastr» ot 8 janvarja 2014 goda # 02-03-72, na zapros Akademii gosudarstvennogo upravlenija pri Prezidente Respubliki Uzbekistan ot 26 nojabrja 2013 goda #07/1-1641.
8. Oficial'nyj otvet Instituta prognozirovanija i makrojekonomicheskih issledovanij «Ob indekse sostojanija delovoj sredy Uzbekistana» ot 8 janvarja 2014 goda # 15-08/4, na zapros Akademii gosudarstvennogo upravlenija pri Prezidente Respubliki Uzbekistan
ot 4 dekabrja 2013 goda # 07/1668.
9. Potencial i mehanizm razvitija sfery uslug v mahalljah // Institut social'nyh issledovanij pri Kabinete Ministrov Respubliki Uzbekistan, 2010.
10. Slovar' russkogo jazyka. AN SSSR. Institut russkogo jazyka. – M., 1988. – T. 4. B 749.
11. Timofeev N. S. Mestnoe hozjajstvo i ego rol' v razvitii mestnogo samoupravlenija (postanovka problemy) // Konstitucionnoe i municipal'noe pravo.– 2010. – # 12.
12. Jakimec V. N. Osnovy, principy i mehanizmy mezhsektornogo partnjorstva v Rossii. – Sankt-Peterburg, 2002.




LAW OF THE CIS COUNTRIES
Murtazakulov J. S.
Legislation on dehqan (farm) economies in Tajikistan:establishment and development
In the given article the speech is about development of legislation on dehqan (farm) economies in two historical aspects: tsar and post-revolution Tajikistan. Legislation of tsar and post-revolution period are analysed and conclusion are made.
Keywords: dehqan (farm) economies, legislation, land, land private property, feodal and burguase property.
Work bibliographic list
1. Aminov A.M. Jekonomicheskoe razvitie Srednej Azii. So vtoroj poloviny XIX v. do pervoj mirovoj vojny. – Tashkent, 1959.
2. Abdurahimova M.Ja. K voprosu osvoenija Golodnoj stepi // Tr. Samarkand. gos.un-ta. – 1970. – Vyp. 182.– S. 108-117.
3. Abdurahimova N.A. Revoljucionnoe dvizhenie v Turkestane posle pervoj russkoj revoljucii (1907-1916 gg.). //Nauch. Tr. Tashk. gos. un-ta. – 1970. – Vyp: 346. – S. 65-86.
4. Tahirov F.T. Stanovlenie sovetskogo prava v Tadzhikistane. – Dushanbe, 1987.
5. Kushmatov A. Tadzhikskoe krest'janstvo v konce XIX i nachale XX veka. -Dushanbe, 1998.
6. Iskandarov B.I. Vostochnaja Buhara i Pamir v period prisoedinenija Srednej Azii k Rossii. – Dushanbe, – 1960
7. Kisljakov N.A. Ocherki po istorii Karategina. K istorii Tadzhikistana.- Stalinabad, 1954.
8. Kisljakov N.A. Sledy pervobytnogo kommunizma u gornyh tadzhikov doliny Hingou. – M.; L., 1936.
9. Dzhalilov I. Vozniknovenie i razvitie sovetskogo zemel'nogo prava v Uzbekistane. -Tashkent, 1970.
10. Rostislavov M.N. Ocherk vidov zemel'noj sobstvennosti i pozemel'nyj vopros v Turkestanskom krae.– SPb., 1879.
11. Juldashev M.Ju. Feodal'noe zemlevladenie v Hive HIH v.//Izv. AN Uz SSR. – 1959. – # 3.
12. Hidaja. Kommentarii musul'manskogo prava. – Tashkent, 1893. – T.3.
13. Koran: Zakonodatel'naja kniga Mahammedanskogo verouchenija. – Kazan', 1894.
14. Palen K.K. Shariatnye stat'i o pravovyh otnoshenijah musul'manskogo naselenija Turkestanskogo kraja. –Tashkent, 1910.





LAW OF THE CIS COUNTRIES
Abdulloev H. A, Subhonov A. I., Askharov A. R.
Demographic development and labor market in transitional economics in the republic of Tajikistan
This article reviews the issues of demographic development and labor market formations in transitional period. The authors have made some theoretical findings and conclusions to define the demographic development and labor market. Recommendations have been offered for labor market regulation in transition to market economy, in order to work out policy to decrease the level of unemployment and to create jobs for economic active population.
Keywords: demographic processes, fertility, marriages, divorces, mortality, labor market, natural resource of productive forces, unemployment, migration.
Work bibliographic list
1. Islamov S.I. Sushhnost' chelovecheskogo kapitala. //Sbornik statej «Perehodnyj period: tendencii social'nogo i jekonomicheskogo razvitija Tadzhikistan.– Dushanbe, 2001. – # 2.
2. Roshhin S.Ju., Solncev S.A. Rynok truda top-menedzherov v Rossii. – M.: GU VShJe. 2006.
3. Tadzhikistan: 20 let gosudarstvennoj nezavisimosti.–Dushanbe: Agentstvo po statistike RT, 2011.
4. Statisticheskij ezhegodnik RT. – Dushanbe: Agentstvo po statistike RT, 2013.
5. Demograficheskij ezhegodnik Respubliki Tadzhikistan. –Dushanbe: Agentstvo po statistike RT, 2013.Gosudarstvennoe agentstvo statistiki Respubliki Tadzhikistan, Dushanbe, 2013.
6. Rynok truda v Respublike Tadzhikistan. –Dushanbe: Agentstvo po statistike RT, 2013.




LAW OF THE CIS COUNTRIES
Babaev A. A.
State migration policy and return of migrants – citizens of Tajikistan
The article analyzes the migration legislation of the Republic of Tajikistan on the return of migrant workers to their country of origin and their reintegration into society, and the problems out of the situation  taking into account the application of international practice.
Keywords: migration, return of labor migrants, diaspora, overseas compatriots, reintegration, adaptation of migrants.
Work bibliographic list
1. Doklad OON «Mezhdunarodnaja migracija iz stran s perehodnoj jekonomikoj v 1980-1999 godah».
2. Statisticheskij ezhegodnik Respubliki Tadzhikistan. – Dushanbe, 2014.
3. Koncepcija gosudarstvennoj migracionnoj politiki Respubliki Tadzhikistan, 1998 g.
4. Programma vneshnej trudovoj migracii grazhdan Respubliki Tadzhikistan na 2006 – 2010 gody, 2006g.
5. Koncepcija privlechenija zarubezhnyh sootechestvennikov v kachestve partnerov razvitija otechestva, 2010 g.
6. Nacional'naja Strategija trudovoj migracii grazhdan Respubliki Tadzhikistan za granicu na period 2011 – 2015 gody, 2001 g.
7. Vsemirnyj Bank, Vyborochnye social'no-jekonomicheskie pokazateli i svjaz' s trudovoj migraciej, Set' jekspertov-praktikov v sfere migracii i denezhnyh perevodov (MIRPAL), 2010.
8. Iz otchetov Migracionnoj sluzhby Tadzhikistana,2013 – 2014 gg.
9. Postanovlenie Pravitel'stva Respubliki Tadzhikistan ot 5 fevralja 2015 goda, #50 «O plane meroprijatij po predotvrashheniju vozdejstvija vozmozhnyh riskov na nacional'nuju jekonomiku».
10. Iz otcheta Migracionnoj sluzhby Tadzhikistana za 2015 g.
11. Materialy respublikanskoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii: Problemy trudovoj migracii i puti ih reshenija. – Dushanbe, «Irfon», 2007.
12. Materialy Respublikanskoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii, tom 1: Trudovaja migracija, denezhnye perevody vneshnih trudovyh migrantov, razvitie predprinimatel'stva v Respublike Tadzhikistan. – Dushanbe, 2011.




LAW OF THE CIS COUNTRIES
Nematov A. R.
Law-making activity factors in Tajikistan
In article such right forming factors as national and ecological which still didn't lose the value and continue to play an important role in definition of the directions of law-making policy of the state and formation of the contents of the modern legislation of the Republic of Tajikistan are considered.
Keywords: Republic of Tajikistan, law-making, national factor, ecological factor, law-making policy.
Work bibliographic list
1. Ahbori (Vestnik) Madzhlisi Oli Respubliki Tadzhikistan. – 2011. – # 3.
2. Bogoljubov S.A. Pravotvorchestvo v sfere jekologii. –M., 2010.
3. Brinchuk M.M. Blagoprijatnaja okruzhajushhaja sreda –vazhnejshaja kategorija prava // Zhurnal rossijskogo prava. – 2008.– # 9.
4. Dialog S.A. Bogoljubova i Zh.S. Eljubaeva ob opyte Rossii i Kazahstana // Zhurnal zarubezhnogo zakonodatel'stva i sravnitel'nogo pravovedenija. – 2012.–# 4.
5. Dubovickij V. Dialog gosudarstva i religii v svete civilizacionnogo podhoda (na primere Rossii i Tadzhikistana) // Gosudarstvo i religija: poisk putej prodolzhenija dialoga / Otv. red. P. D. Shozimov, R.Hajdarov. – Dushanbe, 2005
6. Koldaeva N. P., Kumanin E. V., Levanskij V.A., Polenina S. V. Klassifikacija faktorov i osnovanija postroenija ih sistemy // Zakonodatel'naja sociologija/ otv. red. V. P. Kazimirchuk i S. V. Polenina. – M.,2010.
7. Mickevich A. V. Pravotvorchestvo v SSSR. – M., 1974;Nashic A. Pravotvorchestvo: teorija i zakonodatel'naja tehnika. – M., 1974; Polenina S.V. Zakonotvorchestvo v Rossijskoj Federacii. – M., 1996
8. Nematov A. R. Pravotvorchestvo v Respublike Tadzhikistan. – Germany, LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing,2013.
9. Nikishin V.V. Jekologicheskoe zakonodatel'stvo: pravotvorchestvo





LAW OF THE CIS COUNTRIES
Makhmadov P. A.
The role of information security of political communication in ensuring security (experience of Tajikistan)
Political communication in the world today takes on special features related to the impact on the communication process a variety of factors. The very communicative process involves the use of modern information and communication technologies. The article focuses on the role of information security in political communication security. The author seeks to show the spectrum of problems related to security on the experience of Tajikistan.
Keywords: communication, politics, security, information, communication space.
Work bibliographic list
1. Grachev M.N. Politicheskaja kommunikacija: teoreticheskie koncepcii, modeli, vektory razvitija. – M.:Prometej. – 2004.
2. Protokol o vzaimodejstvii gosudarstv-chlenov ODKB po protivodejstviju prestupnoj dejatel'nosti v informacionnoj sfere (25.12.2014)
3. Gerbner G. Institutional pressures on mass communicators // The Sociology of Mass Media Communicators: Sociological Review Monograph.Vol. 13. / Ed.: R. Halmos. – University of Keels, 1969.
4. Solov'ev A.I. Politicheskaja kommunikacija: k probleme teoreticheskoj identifikacii. // Polis. –2002. – # 3.




LAW OF THE CIS COUNTRIES
Kalandarzoda M. S.
Formation and development institute of the child in Tajikistan
The article deals with the formation of the institute of child rights and the legalization of the legislation of the Republic of Tajikistan, as one of the most important factors in the formation of the rule of law after independence.
Keywords: rule of law, human rights, the rights of the child, the Ombudsman, the property rights
relationship.
Work bibliographic list
1. Badal'janc Ju. S. Prava cheloveka – Rjazan', 2006.
2. Gluharjova L. Teorija prav cheloveka: predmet, metodologija, jetapy razvitija//Pravo i zhizn'. Jelektronnaja versija. [Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa:www.law-n-life.ru.
3. Konstitucija Respubliki Tadzhikistan. Sb. Konstitucija i konstitucionnye zakony Respubliki Tadzhikistan. – Dushanbe, 2005.
4. Mezhdunarodnyj bill' o pravah cheloveka. – Dushanbe, 2002.
5. Prava cheloveka: Uchebnik dlja vuzov/Otv.red. E. A. Lukashjova. – M.: Norma, 2001.
6. Prava cheloveka. Uchebno-metodicheskoe posobie. Otv.red.- Dinorshoev A.M. – Dushanbe, 2011





LAW OF FOREIGN STATES
Akhmedov N. I.
On the legal features regulation of the fight against corruption outside the United States
The article addresses the issue of the United States' role in the fight against corruption on a global scale. As seen from the content of the Anti-corruption in the United States there is no such phenomenon as corruption. Provisions of this Act are aimed at fighting corruption outside the United States. The author's position is expressed in the review of the legal framework related c corruption officials. The author in a constructive scientific debate describes the actual state of affairs, reflecting the corrupt nature of the actions of US officials.
Keywords: corruption, the issuer, the company, subsidiaries, jurisdiction, transaction, proving the public, immunity, verification, reporting.
Work bibliographic list
1. Astanin V. V. Nauchno-prakticheskij kommentarij k federal'nomu zakonu ot 25 dekabrja 2008 goda # 273– FZ «O protivodejstvii korrupcii». – SPb., Juridicheskij centr Press. – 2009.
2. 2Dobren'kov V. I., Ispravnikova N. R. Korrupcija:sovremennye podhody k issledovaniju. – M., Akademicheskij proekt. – 2009.
3. Ibragimov S. I., Urunova Sh. A. Sudebno-pravovye reformy v Respublike Tadzhikistan i jeffektivnost' administrativno-pravovyh mer bor'by s korrupciej. – Dushanbe, Donish. – 2012.
4. O protivodejstvii korrupcii: sbornik rossijskogo zakonodatel'stva i mezhdunarodnyh dokumentov. –M., Jurid.lit. – 2009.
5. Chashin A. N. Korrupcija v Rossii: strategija, taktika i metody bor'by. – M., Delo i Servis. – 2009.
6. Chashin A.N. Kommentarij k federal'nomu zakonu «O protivodejstvii korrupcii» ot 19 dekabrja 2008 goda # 273 – FZ (postatejnyj nauchno-prakticheskij).– M., Delo i Servis. – 2010.




LAW OF FOREIGN STATES
Akchurin T. F.
American law institute and its impact on the development of modern us legal system
The American legal system is in its structure and content of the complicated and confusing, the availability of equity and common law raises many questions, both by foreign as well as in American lawyers. Adds an complexity to the understanding of the American legal system, there are several legal systems in the United States, since it is a federation. The US Constitution huge number of powers to establish the rule of law reserves to the states. To aid in the understanding of American law and the decisions of such issues creates a number of non-profit organizations, including the American Law Institute. The article analyzes the role and place of the American Law Institute in the US legal system and that the specific assistance that the Institute has practicing lawyers, judges and teachers for a better understanding and application of American law.
Keywords: American Law Institute (ALI), US legal system, common law, secondary sources of American law, restatement of the law, principles of the law, model code, Model Penal Code (MPC), Uniform Commercial Code (UCC).
Work bibliographic list
1. Akchurin T. F. Slovar' po sravnitel'nomu pravovedeniju. – M.: Orbita-M, 2015.
2. Petrova E. A. Statuty i precedenty v sisteme istochnikov amerikanskogo prava: Monografija / E. A. Petrova. – Ivanovo: Ivan. gos. un-t, 2007.
3. Fridmjen L. M. Vvedenie v amerikanskoe pravo. Perevod s anglijskogo / Pod red.: Kalantarova. – M.; Per.:Sedun G.: Progress-Univers, 1993.
4. Shumilov V.M. Pravovaja sistema SShA. – 3-e izd. – M.:Mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija, 2013.
5. Arhiv vseh restejtmentov pervoj serii (redakcii)[Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://dla.library.upenn.edu/dla/ead/detail.html?id=EAD_upenn_biddle_USPULPULALI04001
6. Oficial'nyj sajt Amerikanskogo instituta prava(American Law Institute (ALI) [Jelektronnyj resurs]. –Rezhim dostupa: https://www.ali.org/about-ali/
7. Oficial'nyj sajt biblioteki Harvard Law School [Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://libguides.law.harvard.edu/content.php?pid=103327&sid=1036651;
8. Oficial'nyj sajt Nacional'noj konferencii upolnomochennyh po unifikacii zakonov shtatov(Uniform Law Commission (ULC) ili National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws) http://www.uniformlaws.org/Default.aspx
9. Oficial'nyj sajt Amerikanskogo instituta prava nepreryvnogo juridicheskogo obrazovanija (American Law Institute Continuing Legal Education Group(ALI CLE) – [Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa:https://www.ali-cle.org/
10. proekty Amerikanskogo instituta prava na oficial'nom sajte [Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: https://www.ali.org/projects/
11. American Law Institute. Annual reports. Report of the director.report of the treasurer 70 annual meeting, May 11-14, 1993, Washington, D.C., The American Law Institute.
12. Black’s Law Dictionary 8th ed. (West Group, 2004), (Bryan A. Garner, editor).
13. Bylaws in American Law Institute. Annual reports. Report of the director. report of the treasurer 70 annual meeting, May 11-14, 1993, Washington, D.C., The American Law Institute. – PP. 50-52, 53-54.
14. Douglas M. Branson. The American Law Institute Principles Of Corporate Governance And The Derivative //Washington and Lee Law Review. Volume 43 | Issue 2 Article 4, 3-1-1986
15. John P. Frank. The American Law Institute. 1923-1998//Hofsrta Law Review, Volume 26, No. 3, Spring 1998 –Symposium on the American Law Institute: process. Partisanship, and the restatements of law.
16. Law of the United States: An Overview / by Peter Hay.– Munchen: Beck, 2002 – PP. 14-16; sajt biblioteki Yale Law Library – [Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://library.law.yale.edu/secondary-sources
17. Legal and Economic Principles of World Trade Law. Part of The American Law Institute Reporters Studies on WTO Law. Editors: Henrik Horn, Research Institute of Industrial Economics, StockholmPetros C. Mavroidis, European University Institute, Florence. – The American Law Institute. Philadelphia. Pennsylvania. 2015
18. Llewellyn K. N. Statement to The New York Law Revision Commission // Litowitz D. Perspectives on the Uniform Commercial Code. — Durham, 2001.
19. The American Law Institute. 77aneversary 1923-1998. – The American Law Institute. Philadelphia. Pennsylvania. 1998. –P.9




Bolgov R. V.

Karachay V. A.

COMPARATIVE LAW
Bolgov R. V., Karachay V. A.
Comparative analysis of laws and institutions of open budget in Russia and Kazakhstan
The article is based on an analysis of the institutional and legal framework of the Open Budget in the post-Soviet / Eurasian countries (Russia and Kazakhstan), which are involved in the integration process. Analysis of the legal framework is based on the comparing of laws on Open Budget and their implementation. The authors developed a set of parameters for comparison of legal acts on the Open Budget: basic terms and objectives of the Open Budget; authorities responsible for the implementation of projects on the Open Budget; priorities of Open Budget. Analysis of the implementation of legal documents based on comparison of the countries' positions in the ratings of international organizations, the results of governmen-tal bodies audit, public opinion polls, expert surveys, analysis of media coverage.
Keywords: Open Budget, Fiscal Transparency, Eurasian Integration.
Work bibliographic list
1. Abdrahmanov S. Ministerstvo finansov Respubliki Kazahstan kak organ, otvetstvennyj za obespechenie bjudzhetnoj podotchetnosti. [Jelektronnyj resurs].– Rezhim dostupa: http://budget.kz/publikatsii/issledovatelskie-otchety/02_RoleOfMinistryOfFinanceInBudgetAccountability.pdf (data poseshhenija: 28.01.2016 g.).
2. Bolgov R.V. Jelektronnoe pravitel'stvo i social'nye seti: opyt Germanii // Trudy XV Vserossijskoj ob"edinennoj konferencii «Internet i sovremennoe obshhestvo». – SPb, 2012. – S. 269-273.
3. Bjudzhetnyj kodeks Respubliki Kazahstan ot 4 dekabrja 2008 goda # 95 - IV.
4. Ivanov O.A. Otkrytyj bjudzhet municipal'nyh obrazovanij HMAO-Jugry // Finansy. – #12. – 2012. –S.77-80.
5. Parhimovich O., Vlasov V., Muromcev D. Razrabotka ontologii otkrytyh gosudarstvennyh dannyh na primere rashodov bjudzheta Sankt-Peterburga // Nauchno-tehnicheskij vestnik informacionnyh tehnologij, mehaniki i optiki, # 6 (82), 2012. S. 141-146.
6. Raksina A. Sekretnyj «chulok». Pravitel'stvo prjachet stat'i bjudzheta ot jekspertnogo analiza i obshhestvennogo kontrolja // Novye Izvestija, 15 oktjabrja 2013 g. [Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http:/www.newizv.ru/economics/2013-10-15/190700-sekretnyjchulok.html (data poseshhenija: 28.01.2016 g.).
7. Realizacija v sub"ektah Rossijskoj Federacii meroprijatij po povysheniju prozrachnosti i otkrytosti bjudzheta i bjudzhetnogo processa dlja grazhdan.[Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://budget.open.gov.ru/upload/iblock/30f/30ff2a62ed4a531b0b5f4646d6c291d4.pdf (data poseshhenija: 28.01.2016 g.).
8. Rukovodstvo po obespecheniju prozrachnosti v bjudzhetno-nalogovoj sfere (2007 god). Mezhdunarodnyj valjutnyj fond. [Jelektronnyj resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://www.imf.org/external/np/fad/trans/rus/manualr.pdf (data poseshhenija: 28.01.2016 g.).
9. Turgel' I.D. Rossijskij opyt formirovanija otkrytogo bjudzheta: problemy i perspektivy // Municipalitet: jekonomika i upravlenie. – N 2(5). – 2013.– S. 24-32.
10. Turgel' I.D. Formirovanie «otkrytogo bjudzheta» v Rossijskoj Federacii: dolgosrochnye plany i pervye rezul'taty // Voprosy upravlenija. – N 3. – 2014.– S. 22-30.
11. Ukaz Prezidenta Rossijskoj Federacii 7 maja 2012 goda N 601. http://www.rg.ru/2012/05/09/gosupravleniedok.html (data poseshhenija: 28.01.2016 g.).
12. Farhutdinov I.Z. Evrazijskoe pravovoe prostranstvo: problemy i puti ih preodolenija // Evrazijskij juridicheskij zhurnal, 2009, # 5(12). S.4-6.
13. Alt J., Lassen D.D., Wehner J. It isn’t just about Greece:Domestic politics, transparency and fiscal gimmickry in Europe // British Journal of Political Science, 44 (4), 2014.
P. 707-716.
14. Assessment of budget transparency of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Transparency International, Almaty, 2003.http://www.transparencykazakhstan.org/UserFiles/file/89d.pdf (data poseshhenija: 28.01.2016 g.).
15. Bolgov R., Karachay V., Zinovieva E. Information Society Development in Eurasian Economic Union Countries:Legal Aspects // ACM International Conference Proceeding Series. 8th International Conference on Theory and Practice of Electronic Governance, ICEGOV 2014. Pp. 387-390.
16. Cohen N. The power of expertise? Politician-bureaucrat interactions, national budget transparency and the Israeli health care policy // Policy Studies, 34 (5-6), 2013. P. 638- 654.
17. Duggal R., Acharya N., Garg A. Budget transparency and participation: Recommendations to the fourteenth finance commission // Economic and Political Weekly, 49 (34), 2014. P. 19-22.
18. Harrison T.M., Sayogo D.S. Open budgets and open government: Beyond disclosure in pursuit of transparency, participation and accountability // ACM International Conference Proceeding Series, 2013. P. 235-244.
19. Hu B., Mendoza R.U. Public Health Spending, Governance and Child Health Outcomes: Revisiting the Links// Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, 14(2), 2013. P. 285-311.
20. Makhmutova M., The Budget Process in Caspian Countries. The Experience of Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan //Problems of Economic Transition, Vol. 50, No. 4, 2007. Pp. 24–65.
21. Open Budget Survey. Kazakhstan. International Budget Partnership, 2015. http://www.internationalbudget.org/ wp-content/uploads/OBS2015-CS-Kazakhstan-English.pdf (data poseshhenija: 28.01.2016).
22. Open Budget Survey. Russia. International Budget Partnership, 2015. http://www.internationalbudget.org/wpcontent/uploads/OBS2015-CS-Russia-English.pdf (data
poseshhenija: 28.01.2016 g.).
23. Open Government of the Russian Federation. http://bigovernment.ru/polls/31/ (data poseshhenija: 28.01.2016).
24. Open Government of the Russian Federation. http://otkrytyedannye.bol'shoepravitel'stvo.rf/upload/iblock/5f6/5f6d0c57d8d2eb0d38c5bf5bc2db5bd9.pdf(data poseshhenija: 28.01.2016 g.).
25. Seifert J., Carlitz R., Mondo E. The Open Budget Index (OBI) as a Comparative Statistical Tool, in: Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 15 (1), 2013. P. 87-101.
26. Styrin E., Dmitrieva N. Models for Assessing Openness and Transparency of Executive Authorities // ACM International Conference Proceeding Series. International Conference “Electronic Governance and Open Society: Challenges in Eurasia”, EGOSE, 2015. Pp. 84-87.
27. Wehner J., De Renzio P. Citizens, Legislators, and Executive Disclosure: The Political Determinants of Fiscal Transparency // World Development, 41 (1), 2013. P. 96-108.